From New Hire to Mentor: Bridging the Generation Gap in the Legal Field
As I recently recertified for what is now my seventh year as a Certified Paralegal, I found myself reflecting on where I started and where I stand today. Looking back on nearly ten years in the legal field — working at multiple firms, adapting to different procedures, office cultures, practice areas and the many transitions that naturally occur throughout one’s legal career — I had a realization.
Somewhere along the way, I became the experienced paralegal. I guess, as many millennials might say, I’m in my “girl boss era.”
Ten years in, I wouldn’t necessarily call myself seasoned just yet, but I am experienced. I can put out the countless fires that pop up every day, review and abstract a contract to smithereens, draft countless documents at a moment’s notice, respond to hundreds of emails and I can even research your mom’s uncle’s stepdad’s cat if you want — all with a smile of course.
There is still so much for me to learn, and I hope there always will be. But somewhere between being the new hire asking all the questions and becoming the person everyone comes to for answers, something changed. The funny part is that I don’t really know when it happened. One day, I just woke up and realized I could answer the questions that once intimidated me.
That realization got me thinking about the next generation of paralegals entering our profession. As experienced paralegals, it is easy to slip into autopilot. We know what to do and when to do it. We know our attorneys. Our work product speaks for itself, and our opinions are often valued. Simply put, we know our jobs. But then a new face walks through the door, and suddenly we’re reminded that they don’t know what we know, not because they aren’t capable, but because they simply haven’t had the opportunity to learn it yet.
Some new hires come in with office experience and seem to “get it” right away. Others arrive fresh out of school, eager to learn but understandably overwhelmed. Neither is wrong. They’re simply at different starting points.
After years of doing this work, we sometimes forget what it felt like to be brand new. We forget what it was like not knowing the difference between recording a document and filing one, not understanding the various types of pleadings or wondering if we were asking too many questions. We forget how intimidating it can be to remember everyone’s names, navigate unfamiliar software or simply figure out where the office supplies are kept.
Legal work is demanding. It can also be discouraging. Today’s new graduates are entering a profession filled with constant conversations about artificial intelligence replacing the profession. On top of that, there are countless other factors that can shape a new paralegal’s early experience, such as firm size, office culture, salary expectations and varying pay ranges, practice areas, management styles and the overall support they receive during onboarding. When you combine those uncertainties with the inevitable mistakes that come with learning a new profession, it’s easy for any new paralegal to begin questioning whether they truly belong.
As an experienced paralegal, I believe that we have a duty to mentor, foster and encourage our new graduates as they begin their careers. For some, this may require a lot of handholding; for others, this may involve sharing tidbits of information that will be useful to them throughout their entire career. As I’ve grown in my own career, I’ve made it a point to be someone who helps new colleagues feel welcome. That doesn’t mean I pretend every day is perfect or sell unrealistic expectations. Quite the opposite, I try to manage expectations the same way I do with my attorneys. I let my new peers know that there will be busy days, stressful days and days when they’ll feel like they’re drinking from a fire hose. That’s normal.
More importantly, I want them to know they don’t have to figure it all out alone.
I encourage questions. I reassure them that it’s okay not to remember everyone’s names after the first day. I explain the little things that no one teaches you in school, but everyone eventually learns. Sometimes mentoring isn’t about teaching legal concepts at all; it’s simply making someone feel comfortable enough to ask for help. The little things matter.
If I’m waiting behind someone at the copier or scanner, I don’t hover over them. I wait patiently. I ask if they need help instead of making them feel rushed. A small act of patience can build confidence, and confidence encourages people to ask questions before mistakes become bigger problems.
The same goes for office habits. If I notice someone saving documents with confusing file names or organizing files in a way that makes it harder for the team, I’ll gently explain why consistency matters. It may seem insignificant to them now, but one day they’ll be searching through a folder filled with files named “PDF 61458” and realize exactly why those little details matter.
The goal isn’t criticism — it’s setting them up for success.
Of course, mentorship isn’t a one-way street. New graduates bring fresh perspectives, new technology skills, enthusiasm and ideas that challenge us to rethink the way we’ve always done things. They remind us that growth never really stops, no matter how many years we’ve spent in the profession.
Bridging the generation gap isn’t about age. It’s about perspective.
Every experienced paralegal was once the nervous new graduate hoping someone would be patient enough to answer one more question. Every confident professional started exactly where today’s new hires are standing.
If we want to strengthen our profession, we must choose patience over frustration, guidance over criticism and mentorship over assumptions. One day, the graduate nervously standing at the copier will become the experienced paralegal someone else looks up to. Today’s overwhelmed graduate is tomorrow’s experienced paralegal. I hope, when that day comes, they’ll remember what it felt like to be new.
Keyonna Smith is a North Carolina Certified Paralegal primarily focusing on commercial real estate transactions and complex title research matters at Jordan Price Wall Gray Jones & Carlton, PLLC, in Raleigh, North Carolina. She is an active member and Council member of the North Carolina Bar Association Paralegal Division with a passion for the ever-evolving field of real property law. Whether she’s fact-finding through a complex chain of title or pursuing a new hobby, Keyonna is always eager to learn, tackle a challenge and greet every opportunity with a smile.
***
The Paralegal Division Blog is managed by the Division’s Communications Committee. Via the blog, the Communications Committee provides information written by attorneys, paralegals, and other experts designed specifically for paralegals in the areas of substantive law, ethics, technology, paralegal practice advice, and more. If you are interested in signing up to submit a blog post on a future date, you can do so here. When you are ready to submit a blog post, you can do so by using this form.
You may also wish to participate in the Division by using our virtual suggestion box to submit suggestions/ideas to the Division Council, nominating a paralegal for Paralegal Spotlight, or completing the Paralegal Spotlight Questionnaire if you are nominating yourself. If you are interested in volunteering with the Communications Committee, please contact the Communications Committee Chair at [email protected]. If you are interested in joining other division committees, you can review a list of committees and sign up here.