Workmanship Claims on Trial: The Expert Witness Divide

Christian, a white man with brown hair, wears a white shirt, dark blue tie, and black suit.By Christian Lunghi 

In construction litigation, it’s easy to focus on the visible damage — the crooked beam, the leaking roof, or the puddle in the basement — and think, “any jury can see what’s wrong here.” But when it comes to proving a breach of the applicable standard of care, appearances may not be enough. If you’re litigating claims based on bad workmanship, the need for expert testimony is not just a good idea — it’s often essential.

When Is an Expert Required?

Courts routinely recognize that an expert is necessary to establish a breach of professional or trade standards unless the issue is obvious to a layperson. In the construction context, this means demonstrating that the contractor failed to perform according to the workmanship standards expected of builders in the jurisdiction.

Read more

Managing Construction Cost Escalations Triggered by Tariffs and Market Volatility

Jeff, a white man with brown hair, wears a pale blue shirt and a dark grey jacket.By Jeffrey M. Reichard

Recent tariffs imposed by the Trump administration on foreign imports — and the retaliatory tariffs from China and other nations — are poised to drive up the cost of construction materials. This raises a critical question: who in the contracting chain bears the risk of these escalating prices? Is it the project owner, general contractor, subcontractor, or material supplier?

The answer typically depends on the contractual agreements between the parties and the stage of the project when the price increase or tariff is introduced. For example, once a binding fixed-price contract has been executed, obtaining additional compensation for cost increases becomes far more challenging. However, regardless of the project phase, contracting parties can take steps to mitigate their exposure to price escalations.

Read more

Cybersecurity in the Construction Industry: Key Threats and Steps Construction Companies Can Take to Mitigate Risks

Jonathan, a white man with brown hair, wears a white shirt, red tie and black jacket. By Jonathan W. Massell

The digital age has enabled the construction industry to utilize new technologies to increase efficiencies and become more streamlined. Electronic communications, online banking, automated systems and digital storage of key information are now standard aspects of even the most low-tech companies in the construction industry. It is easy to take these systems for granted. But have your clients ever wondered what they would do if they were completely shut out of their company emails, operating system and electronic databases? Could your clients operate without these systems and data? What could happen if this data falls into the wrong hands? How much would your clients pay to regain access to their systems and data?

Read more

Executive Order 14275: Legal and Operational Impacts on Federal Contractors

Todd, a white man with brown hair, wears a white shirt, red tie and navy blue suit. By Todd A. Jones

On April 15, 2025, President Donald J. Trump signed Executive Order 14275, titled Restoring Common Sense to Federal Procurement, initiating a comprehensive overhaul of the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR). This directive aims to streamline the federal procurement process by eliminating unnecessary regulatory burdens and enhancing efficiency. The Executive Order acknowledges that “federal procurement under the FAR receives consistently negative assessments regarding its efficiency” and mandates that the FAR be amended to include only provisions “required by statute or that are otherwise necessary to support simplicity and usability, strengthen the efficacy of the procurement system, or protect economic or national security interests.”

Read more

What’s in a Name?

Natalia, a white woman with brown hair, wears a light blue blouse.By Natalia L. Talbot

Three things for general contractors to know if you are considering a business name change.

You may want to change the “look and feel” of your company’s branding (i.e., “rebranding”) for the purpose of influencing how your company is perceived by current or potential consumers, the business community, or stakeholders. This marketing initiative might include changing the “look and feel” of your company’s name and/or logo on your website, social media, letterhead, contracts, company vehicles, commercial office space, and so on. You might think that, as long as the name on your corporate filings, legal documents, or bank accounts doesn’t change, all these other changes are simply “marketing initiatives.” But, for general contractors licensed under North Carolina law (G.S. § 87-1 et seq.), rebranding is more than a marketing initiative.

Read more

Navigating Rule 5: Can I Just Send You an Email?

Christian, a white man with brown hair, wears a white shirt, dark blue tie, and black suit.By Christian Lunghi 

Welcome to the future — where even serving pleadings requires a login screen.

. . .

In October of 2020, the North Carolina legislature gave Rule 5 of the North Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure a digital makeover. Rule 5, as amended, wholeheartedly embraces the electronic filing system and makes it the go-to method for serving applicable pleadings and papers. Gone are the days of sending opposing counsel an email containing your discovery requests and responses. Now, you need to log into eCourts, toss your pleading into the digital realm of Tyler Technologies, and cross your fingers.

Okay, put down your pitchforks. I know we should embrace a system that eases access to the courts.

Read more

The Myth Behind North Carolina’s Mandatory Construction Warranty

Paul, a white man with dark hair, wears a checkered shirt. The photograph is in black and white. By Paul A. Capua

The first time a general contractor client mentioned, matter-of-fact, that North Carolina law required general contractors to provide a one-year construction warranty on their work, I was worried. As a construction lawyer who frequently negotiates and drafts construction contracts and warranty clauses for a living, I should know that. How could I have missed it?

Read more

Construction Law – Legal Updates

Christian, a white man with brown hair, wears a white shirt, dark blue tie, and black suit.By Christian Lunghi

Hello, everyone:

Below are some legal updates from your Communications Committee.

Big thanks are given to Zachary N. Layne at Hannah Sheridan & Cochran, LLP for providing much of the information used in this post.

If you see anything in need of correction, feel free to drop a reply below.

I look forward to seeing you all in Asheville this September!

Christian Lunghi
Anderson Jones, PLLC
(984) 344-9309


eCourts Counties

To date, eCourts is live in 38 counties: Alamance, Beaufort, Buncombe, Camden, Chatham, Cherokee, Chowan, Clay, Currituck, Dare, Durham, Franklin, Gates, Graham, Granville, Guilford, Harnett, Haywood, Henderson, Hyde, Jackson, Johnston, Lee, Macon, Martin, Mecklenburg, Orange, Pasquotank, Perquimans, Person, Polk, Swain, Transylvania, Tyrrell, Vance, Wake, Warren, and Washington.

On October 14, 2024, the following 11 counties will go live on eCourts: Anson, Cabarrus, Cumberland, Hoke, Montgomery, Moore, Randolph, Richmond, Scotland, Stanly, and Union.

Roadway Construction Appropriations

There has been a significant increase in roadway construction in the current draft of the 2024 appropriations bill for FY 2024-2025, from $77,543,078 in 2023 legislation to $117,543,078 in 2024 legislation. The 2024 appropriations bill is making its way through the Senate.

NC State Bar Ethics Opinions Adopted in 2024

2023 Formal Ethics Opinion 3:

  • Opinion provides that a lawyer may allow a third-party business to install a self-service kiosk in the lawyer’s office for the provision of ignition lock services but may not receive rent or referral fees, and further concludes that a lawyer may be included in the business’s advertising efforts upon compliance with Rule 7.4.

2023 Formal Ethics Opinion 4:

  • Opinion rules that the intentional selection of another lawyer’s unique firm trade name in a keyword advertisement campaign is prohibited, but that prohibition does not apply when the trade name is also a common search term.

Legislative Bills in Progress/Vetoed

Senate Bill 767: Affects N.C.G.S. 6-21.2, attorneys fees in debt instruments.

  • 14-day timeframe to pay without incurring attorney fees

House Bill 556: involved Tenancy in Common, e-Notary, and small claims court.

  • Vetoed in early July by Gov. Cooper

Senate Bill 166: involved, among others, state building codes and regulations for contractors and design professionals.

  • Vetoed in early July by Gov. Cooper

House Bill 957: Home Warranty Regulatory Reform.

  • Consumer protections on home service agreements
  • Rewriting G.S. 66-371
    • Proposed to change from “home appliance service agreement companies soliciting business” to “all home service agreements in use.”
    • Additions:
      • Agreements must include a list of covered items, types of loss or damages agreement covers, statement of purchasers’ rights.
      • A list of approved vendors should be given to the customer.
      • Repair, replacement, maintenance is completed or scheduled for completion with five business days of claim for any covered item that is necessary for heating, air-conditioning, or functioning of bathroom.

New Laws/Rules

Senate Bill 802/Session Law 2024-44

  • Establishment of a statewide C-PACE (Commercial Property Assessed Capital Expenditure) Program that local governments may voluntarily join to allow willing owners of commercial, industrial, agricultural, nonprofit, and multifamily residential properties with five or more dwelling units to obtain low-cost, long-term financing for qualifying improvements, including energy efficiency, water conservation, renewable energy, and resilience projects, secured by an assessment and lien authorized by this Article.

Senate Bill 124/Session Law 2024-11

  • Residential roof replacement or repair contracts subject to five business day cancellation period following insurance claim denial for the work to be performed; no work or payment until this period expires; exception for emergency work

Senate Bill 790/Session Law 2024-25

  • Adds “vexatious complainant” designation.
    • Office of General Counsel and Chair of Grievance Committee may designate a person a “vexatious complainant if the complainant has initiated grievances to the North Carolina State Bar alleging attorney misconduct that even if proven, would fail to constitute a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct, or if available evidence conclusively disproves the allegations, in a manner and volume that amounts to an abuse of the bar disciplinary process.”
    • Complainant can seek review of the designation.
    • “The Office of Counsel may decline to review and process any subsequent grievances from a person designated as vexatious, unless the grievance is submitted with a verification signed by the complainant that the allegations are true under the penalty of perjury, and the grievance is submitted on the complainant’s behalf by a member of the North Carolina State Bar . . .”
  • Adds standing requirements to file grievance.
    • “To be considered by the North Carolina State Bar, a grievance must allege conduct that, if true, constitutes attorney misconduct by violation of this Chapter or under the Rules of Professional Conduct . . .”

House Bill 259/ Session Law 2023-134

  • In NC, Privilege licenses for attorneys are no longer required.
  • Effective July 1, 2024.
  • Last license period – (July 1, 2023 – June 30, 2024).

Noncompetes

  • Under the final Noncompete Rule, the FTC adopts a comprehensive ban on new noncompetes with all workers, including senior executives.
    • The final rule provides that it is an unfair method of competition – and therefore a violation of Section 5 – for employers to enter into noncompetes with workers.
  • For existing noncompetes, the final rule adopts a different approach for senior executives than for other workers. For senior executives, existing noncompetes can remain in force. Existing noncompetes with workers other than senior executives are not enforceable after the effective date.

DBA and DBRA → DOL has enacted the “Final Rule”

  • Changed definitions:
    • Contractor – applies to prime and subcontractors.
    • Subcontractor – “any contractor that agrees to perform or be responsible for the performance of any part of a contract that is subject wholly or in part to the labor standards provisions of any of the laws referenced in § 5.1.”
    • Prime contractor – cross-withholding now allowed when affiliates of prime contractor violate DBA.
    • Material supplier – excluded from the definition of contractor with some narrow exceptions and clarifies that material supplies are not covered by DBA and DBRA.
    • Building or work; Public building or public work – now includes installation of solar panels, wind turbines, broadband and electric car charging stations.
    • Site of the work – any location where a significant portion of building or work is constructed if the site is dedicated exclusively or almost exclusively to performance of a single DBRA contract for a specific period of time.
  • Applies to prime contracts and subcontracts.
  • Prime contractors and upper-tier subcontractors must pay back wages when lower-tier subcontractors violate the final rule.
    • Prime → responsible for back wages of subcontractor without a showing of intent
    • Upper-tier subcontractor → responsible for back wages if there is a showing of intent.
  • Interest (compounded daily) now added to back wages and other monetary relief.
  • Anti-retaliation provision for those reporting violations of DBRA
  • Wage Determinations
    • General wage determinations for a particular geographic area are now the default.
    • Project wage determinations are the exception.
    • Wage determinations must be updated after award if construction is added that is not within the original scope of work.
    • Wage determinations must be updated annually for projects that extend over a period of time and aren’t tied to completion of a specific project.
  • Prevailing Wages
    • If no majority wage rate → a wage rate is now considered prevailing if it is paid to at least 30% of workers in a particular classification (previously 50%)
    • If there is no prevailing rate → weighed average rate used
    • Can also count functionally equivalent wage rates for determining prevailing rate: zone rates, escalator-clause rates, night-shift differential and combined hourly-fringe rates.
    • Non-collectively bargained wage rates may be updated no more than once every 3 years.
    • Area unit → now includes circumstance-specific alternatives
      • Multi-county project – option to include counties’ data and issue single wage rate per classification.
      • Highway projects – can use state highway districts or other state geographic subdivisions instead of counties.
    • Can now mix rural and metropolitan data
      • If insufficient data at county level, surrounding counties data may be used.
      • Rural and metropolitan data can be combined at supergroup level or statewide (as last resort) prior to concluding no sufficient data exists.
    • State or local prevailing wage rates for highway and nonhighway construction may be used now.
  • Litigation
    • Lawsuits have been filed to challenge the final rule in federal court in Eastern and Northern District of Texas.

Welcome, Construction Law Section Members!

Caroline, a white woman with blond hair, wears a bright pink blouse, a black jacket and a pearl necklace. By Caroline Trautman

For those of you who don’t know me, I’m Caroline Trautman, Chair of the NCBA Construction Law Section for the 2024-2025 bar year. As a fan of new years, fresh starts and all the fun things that come with them (school supplies, anyone?) I’m excited for what’s in store for our section this year.

Thanks to the hard work of our Deskbook and CLE committees, we expect to release the 9th Edition of the Construction Law Deskbook, and on September 20-21, we’ll meet in beautiful downtown Asheville for a Fall Construction CLE titled “The Art and Science of Dispute Resolution: Winning Your Construction Case.” This program will be administered jointly with the South Carolina Bar and include CLE credit for both North Carolina and South Carolina. Plans for a winter program in Cary are underway. Additionally, our Pro Bono committee is working to connect our section with non-profit associations doing capital improvement projects, giving our attorney members a unique opportunity to give back to the community by assisting the non-profits with legal needs. Our many other committees are also working to keep our section connected to organizations like the AIA, ABA Forum on Construction Law, CAGC, UMCNC, YLD, Paralegal Division, and many more. Last but not least, we’re hoping that our recent trend of more in-person socials and other gatherings will continue, ideally in multiple regions of the state.

Read more

The Building Envelope: A Perspective

By Mark Stewart, RRC CEI, and Jeffrey Martin, RRC, RRO, CEI, REWO, CDT

Mark Stewart, a white man with a grey beard, wears a white shirt with blue plaid.

Mark Stewart

Jeffrey Martin, a white man brown hair and a grey beard, wears a blue and grey plaid shirt.

Jeffrey Martin

The construction industry has currently been running at a breakneck pace. This pace, combined with the advent of a pandemic, which brought us material shortages and delays, and a workforce shortage, put contractors in a tough spot to bring quality-built projects in on time and under budget. When the delays began, it forced contractors and designers to look for alternative material options that were more readily available. These new alternative materials, without intense scrutiny of their application, could affect the performance of the building envelope.

For example, in the case of wood-framed multi-family construction, the availability of polyisocyanurate (iso) rigid roof insulation was delayed due to shortages of raw materials. Iso was then replaced with a coverboard, and alternate insulation, such as fiberglass batt insulation, was used below the roof deck. This moved the dew point above the insulation, and thus, the interior moisture condensates on the underside of the membrane. The moisture then was at the deck level and began to saturate the wood deck. Over a short period of time, the deck fails prematurely and the increased levels of moisture in the attic space create the perfect environment for biological growth . . . mold. This is just one example of many instances of where the building envelope was compromised.

Read more