Do the Hard Things
To our practice group leader, I must have looked like the golden retriever who had just run up to the back door holding a slobbery tennis ball in its mouth. I could not have been more excited about having passed the 2,100-hour bonus threshold and must have been radiating puppy-like enthusiasm.
And then it hit like a rolled-up newspaper: “Marc, that’s great, but last year I billed more hours than that.”
The prevailing sentiment in law school seemed to be — race to partnership and then cruise down easy street. Turns out that’s not exactly how it goes. But maybe that’s a good thing.
As a partner in two different law firms for over 15 years, the hardened lesson learned that day has dissolved into a more honest reality — partnership (and the seniority that comes with it) involves doing the hard things, many of which are not measured in increments of one-tenth of an hour.
But while some of the things that come along with partnership and responsibility aren’t very glamourous (staffing issues, billing, collections, meetings), there are rewarding parts that no one tells you about in law school. There are also the more difficult parts that we shouldn’t shy away from.
Mentoring
While some of the partners I worked for as a young associate weren’t always the kindest and gentlest, looking back, I think many of them, or at least the good ones, earnestly enjoyed helping me to grow. While I’m sure I’m not the easiest person to work with, I try to mix constructive criticism with healthy doses of enthusiasm and appreciation. Watching an associate smile after a well-received argument or sit down after a first courtroom appearance is about as good as it gets. Better yet, watching an associate struggle with a legal issue or procedure for the first time only to breeze through it the next is pure gold.
Exercising freedom to choose
As an associate, I had very little choice in my assignments. I’m grateful for this because it exposed me to a variety of areas of law, subject matters, practice styles and client types. From these experiences, I believe I discerned the most important lesson — to be yourself or as I like to tell my clients — “you be you.” I have found with the authority of partnership, exercised appropriately, comes a great sense of self and purpose. It allows us to choose areas of practice, practice philosophies and maybe most importantly, the type of clients we want to represent.
Telling clients no
We’ve all heard it: with great power comes great responsibility. Too often I see senior attorneys willing to carry the water for their clients. Whether it’s including language in a complaint, posturing during settlement, opening a mediation, negotiating an employment agreement or making arguments in court, it’s clear when attorneys haven’t been willing to tell their clients no. This isn’t good for the lawyer, whose reputation outlasts any client relationship, or, I would argue, the client, and definitely not our profession. Like a tenured professor, the position of partner should give us more room to say no. No to clients who want to dish out vendettas, take advantage of the legal system or pressure lawyers to bend their moral compass.
Declining clients
As an employment lawyer, I often counsel clients going into new jobs to trust their intuition. Lawyers should do the same. We all know when a client relationship isn’t going to work out. I am fortunate that my practice allows me to screen clients through a paid consultation, typically regarding the enforceability of a restrictive covenant or the advisability of pursuing a legal claim. I can make the choice of whether to represent a client or to politely decline the representation. But partners have the benefit over associates of choosing who they — and their firm — will represent, and that agency is powerful.
Pushing back appropriately
My mother would probably say that I was made to practice law because I love to argue. But my own (fictional) lawyer would argue that I am passionate about my beliefs. I’ve seen far too many lawyers, though, cling to arguments that just won’t hold water, at least in a judge’s skeptical eyes. Rather than concede minor points, I’ve seen lawyers die on hills of little to no consequence. At the same time, one of the hidden advantages of partnership is the deference that comes with the title. While it should be wielded judiciously, and I would argue for the greater good, partners should not be afraid to stand on principle.
Having difficult conversations
There has been plenty of talk about the loss of collegiality among the legal profession. Some blame the lack of in-person interaction, others claim it’s due to the size of the growing bar and some blame the rise of electronic communication. I believe it’s, at least in part, because lawyers aren’t willing to have honest and open conversations with opposing counsel. Or, as I sometimes like to say, adults should have adult conversations with other adults. Lawyers are paid to advance our clients’ interests, and no one wants to lose an important client, but the stature that partnership gives us provides us the room to have unvarnished conversations with other lawyers and not simply pass on the demands of our clients.
Cultivating something to pass on
Law firms seem to struggle with transition plans, and, even more so, execution of those plans. We think about things like passing clients to junior lawyers and how to handle retiring partners financially. I contend that we should be more concerned with the ethos and the fabric we are trying to pass along. I have long said that employees work for people — here, associates work for partners — but law firms, like corporations, have identities. Those identities, sometimes referred to as reputations, are developed over time and carry great weight. Partners should spend time thinking about not just the kind of person they want to be but the kind of place where people want to work. After all, no one will remember how many hours you billed, but they will remember how you made them feel.